Surgical fasciectomy of the trapezius muscle combined with neurolysis of the Spinal accessory nerve; results and long-term follow-up in 30 consecutive cases of refractory chronic whiplash syndrome
© Nystrom et al. 2010
Received: 16 February 2010
Accepted: 07 April 2010
Published: 07 April 2010
Chronic problems from whiplash trauma generally include headache, pain and neck stiffness that may prove refractory to conservative treatment modalities. As has previously been reported, such afflicted patients may experience significant temporary relief with injections of local anesthetic to painful trigger points in muscles of the shoulder and neck, or lasting symptomatic improvement through surgical excision of myofascial trigger points. In a subset of patients who present with chronic whiplash syndrome, the clinical findings suggest an affliction of the spinal accessory nerve (CN XI, SAN) by entrapment under the fascia of the trapezius muscle. The present study was undertaken to assess the effectiveness of SAN neurolysis in chronic whiplash syndrome.
A standardized questionnaire and a linear visual-analogue scale graded 0-10 was used to assess disability related to five symptoms (pain, headache, insomnia, weakness, and stiffness) before, and one year after surgery in a series of thirty consecutive patients.
The preoperative duration of symptoms ranged from seven months to 13 years. The following changes in disability scores were documented one year after surgery: Overall pain decreased from 9.5 +/- 0.9 to 3.2 +/- 2.6 (p < 0.001); headaches from 8.2 +/- 2.9 to 2.3 +/- 2.8 (p < 0.001); insomnia from 7.5 +/- 2.4 to 3.8 +/- 2.8 (p < 0.001); weakness from 7.6 +/- 2.6 to 3.6 +/- 2.8 (p < 0.001); and stiffness from 7.0 +/- 3.2 to 2.6 +/- 2.7 (p < 0.001).
Entrapment of the spinal accessory nerve and/or chronic compartment syndrome of the trapezius muscle may cause chronic debilitating pain after whiplash trauma, without radiological or electrodiagnostic evidence of injury. In such cases, surgical treatment may provide lasting relief.
Among patients who develop permanent debilitating symptoms after whiplash trauma (referred to as chronic whiplash syndrome henceforth), headaches and/or pain and stiffness in the neck and shoulder are the most frequent complaints and reasons for disability [1–3]. In addition, complex patterns of diffuse symptoms, including numbness, paresthesias, vertigo, muscle weakness, or cognitive dysfunction, are common and have been shown to correlate with post traumatic sleep deprivation  or brain stem dysfunction [5–7]. Yet, many patients claim disability in spite of normal findings on standard laboratory tests. This has led to controversy in the literature as some authors argue that symptoms are credible only if corroborated by laboratory findings  while others claim that negative studies do not exclude injury or the validity of a complaint [9, 10].
Chronic symptoms from whiplash trauma have commonly been linked to pathology of the spine and its supporting tissues, i.e. facet joints , spinal ligaments , and intervertebral discs [13, 14]. However, previous investigations have also demonstrated significant symptomatic improvement, including temporarily decreased pain, increased cervical range of motion, and higher peripheral pressure pain thresholds in chronic whiplash patients following injections of local anesthetic into carefully selected areas of focal tenderness in painful muscles . The careful selection of ("key") tender points for injection appears to be critical, as previously described efforts directed at non-specific trigger points have been less effective .
Based upon these observations, a therapeutic approach to chronic whiplash has been developed in which offending tender points that have been identified by a positive response to infiltration with anesthetic are surgically exposed and then excised . Typically, any removed tissue consisted of trapezius fascia, and thus the procedure is reasonably described as a modified fasciectomy. A central feature of the surgical strategy is that following incision and elevation of skin flaps, the patient is awakened for key portions of the procedure to provide real time feedback to assist in identifying and excising of pain generating tissue.
In a similar vein, Hagert et al. have reported that they treated chronic compartment syndrome of the trapezius and entrapment of the spinal accessory nerve (SAN) in patients with a history of overuse syndrome  and a clinical presentation that closely matches the pattern of symptoms observed among patients with chronic whiplash. We therefore posited peripheral nerve entrapment as a possible subcomponent of the chronic whiplash syndrome, and, in a selected group of patients undergoing the procedure described above for chronic whiplash, included neurolysis of SAN. The present manuscript describes the procedures, findings, and long-term outcome in a series of patients undergoing spinal accessory nerve decompression in combination with excision of tender points for chronic pain following whiplash.
The study group consisted of 30 consecutive patients treated by one surgeon (NAN). The indication for surgery was established based upon the following:
unremitting posttraumatic neck pain with a steady state for no less than six months, most typically as a result of a motor vehicle crash-related injury;
lack of lasting response to conservative or minimally-invasive therapeutic procedures, including physical therapy, chiropractic treatment, zygapophyseal blocks, inter alia;
lack of a clearly delineated pain generator pertaining to the spine, such as a disk herniation, fracture, or foraminal or central spinal stenosis;
prompt response to anesthetic infiltration of key tender points in the region of the upper trapezius muscle (at least 50% reduction of the most intrusive symptoms).
Patients are placed in a lateral or beach-chair position on the operating table. Under local anesthesia (1-3 cc of Lidocaine® 0.5%) and short-acting IV sedation (Propofol®), the posterior aspect of the trapezius muscle is exposed through a sagittally oriented skin incision across the shoulder. While the patient is still anesthetized generally thickened fascia, including septae between bundles of the muscle, are excised from the painful area of the muscle according to preoperative skin markings corresponding to the previously identified key tender points. The dissection is continued anteriorly along the leading edge of the trapezius until the SAN was identified. In most of the cases adhesions were identified between the nerve and the underlying fascia.
The patient was then awakened in order to provide feedback during the exploration of areas of greatest focal pain. The skin had been marked pre-operatively to indicate where the key areas of focal tenderness had been identified previously based upon response to local anesthetic. While awake, patients were asked to identify "old" (preoperative) pain and differentiate it from "new" (surgical) pain.
Patients generally signaled incremental improvement during resection of fascia and/or interfascicular septae within the trapezius. Although the SAN neurolysis in some cases was observed to have a direct effect on the patient's headache complaints, the fasciectomy tended to have a greater immediate effect on mobility.
A linear visual analogue scale graded from 0 (not disabling) to 10 (completely disabling) was used to define a 'disability score' for each of five different indices: pain, headache, insomnia, muscle weakness, and neck/shoulder stiffness. Assessments were made for the week preceding surgery, and at follow-up 12-18 months post op.
Hospital charts were reviewed for information pertaining to surgical technique and findings. Outcome data was compiled from questionnaires completed by the patients 12-18 months after the operation.
Student's t-test for paired samples was used for the analysis of outcome data. Statistical significance was defined as p ≤ 0.05.
The study group consisted of 6 males and 24 females presenting to UNMC for treatment for chronic symptoms after whiplash. The average age at the time of surgery was 43 years (range 27-66). The mean and median time from the onset of symptoms until surgery was 41 months (range 7-156) and 24 months, respectively. All of the patients stated that their condition had reached a steady state at the time of the operation.
Fourteen patients reported that their condition had been precipitated by a classic rear-impact motor vehicle crash. The remaining 16 patients reported various other mechanisms of trauma, including falls and sports injuries.
Preoperative complaints and clinical findings
Reported incidence of five separate symptoms, described as disabling by 30 patients prior to surgery.
Reason for disability
Number of patients
Four clinical signs were documented in all cases prior to surgery: (1) asymmetric posture, typically with the shoulder elevated on the side of greatest pain; (2) decreased and painful range of motion in neck and shoulder(s); (3) tenderness to palpation along the horizontal portion of the upper trapezius muscle; and (4) greater than 50% of reduction of pain and increased mobility following infiltration of 2-3 cc of local anesthetic into 1-3 key areas of focal tenderness in the upper trapezius.
Neck/shoulder stiffness, which was observed but not objectively measured in most patients before surgery (Additional file 1), was understood primarily as an expression of pain inhibition.
Key portions of each operation were performed without anesthesia, in order to allow communication between the patient and the surgical team. Thus, the extent of neurolysis and fasciectomy was routinely defined by patients' direct feedback including functional testing, e.g. of mobility (Additional file 2). The procedures were well tolerated by all participants tolerated the procedures well. Recovery was generally rapid, with most patients mobile and ambulatory within the first postoperative days (Additional file 3). There were no major surgical or postoperative complications.
No pathologic findings were noted in any specimens that, in a majority of patients, were submitted for routine microscopy.
Changes in symptom-derived disability scores at follow up one-year after surgery.
1 < 30%
30% < 50%
Symptom-derived disability scores before surgery, and one year after surgery.
9.5 ± 0.9
3.2 ± 2.6
8.2 ± 2.9
2.3 ± 2.8
7.5 ± 2.4
3.8 ± 2.8
7.6 ± 2.6
3.6 ± 2.8
7.0 ± 3.2
2.6 ± 2.7
Fourteen patients of 29 stated that the severity of their sleep deprivation (insomnia) had decreased by 50% or more as a result of the operation. The average number of hours of sleep per night increased from 4 ± 1 to 6 ± 2 for the entire cohort. Similarly, postoperative perception of disability decreased by at least 50% in 15 of the 26 patients reporting weakness, and in 20 of the 28 patients reporting stiffness, in comparison with pre-operative perceptions.
We describe the long-term outcome after surgical fasciectomy and SAN neurolysis for symptoms associated with chronic whiplash pain. In this series of 30 patients, 29 described a lasting overall improvement that they attributed to the treatment, although in one case with satisfactory pain reduction, the procedure resulted in increased neck stiffness. One patient who did not benefit from the surgery reported no degradation or other worsening of symptoms or disability during the year following the operation.
Our results suggest that some of the most common symptoms found in chronic whiplash (e.g. headaches, stiffness of the neck, and pain in the shoulder/neck region) may be secondary to either primary injury in, or secondary dysfunction of the spinal accessory nerve and/or the trapezius muscle. We conclude, with caution, that the condition represents an indication for surgical treatment in selected cases where more conservative measures have proven ineffectual.
What is less clear is how or why the trapezius muscle and SAN are involved in perpetuating the chronic whiplash syndrome. The traditional portrayal of SAN as one of pure motor function has been challenged by anatomical studies [20, 21], and our experience with surgical manipulation of the nerve in alert and unanesthetized patients has confirmed that it indeed is one of mixed sensory and motor function. This finding raises the possibility of SAN injury or entrapment as a cause of neurogenic pain, in addition to and independent of gross loss of motor function [22–24]. Previous reports that surgical neurolysis alone can provide immediate relief of symptoms related to a lesion of SAN further suggest entrapment by scar tissue, rather than nerve damage per se, as a reason for some preoperative symptoms [19, 25].
Based upon the present data we cannot discern to what extent preoperative symptoms were expressions of dysfunction in the SAN versus the trapezius muscle and/or fascia. It has been reported, however, that patients with chronic whiplash syndrome exhibit higher EMG activity in the upper trapezius muscles than healthy control subjects, as well as a reduced ability to relax the muscle to baseline levels after a dynamic task . Larsson et al. found that chronic neck pain may be associated with disturbed microcirculation in the trapezius , and Hagert et al. presented clinical data suggesting chronic trapezius ischemia in a chronic pain syndrome nearly identical to that of our patients . Thus, we cannot exclude that the most beneficial part of the surgery described herein was decompression of a chronic compartment syndrome in parts of the segmented trapezius muscle.
The conclusions that can be drawn from this investigation are limited by the size of the study group, the retrospective, non-randomized study design, and the subjective assessment instrument. It is not possible to draw a firm conclusion as to the relative importance of fasciectomy versus neurolysis, since dissection of the SAN was necessary in all patients to protect the nerve during resection of fascia from the ventral aspect of the trapezius.
The results described herein offer a potentially new direction in evaluation and surgical treatment of chronic whiplash syndrome. Entrapment of the spinal accessory nerve and/or chronic compartment syndrome of the trapezius muscle may cause chronic debilitating pain after whiplash trauma, without radiological or electrodiagnostic evidence of injury. In such cases, surgical treatment may provide lasting relief. Continued research using randomized and controlled study designs will further advance the understanding and extrapolability of the present findings.
Spinal accessory nerve
- Brault JR, Wheeler JB, Sigemund GP, Brault EJ: Clinical response of human subjects to rear-end automobile collisions. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 1998, 79:72–80.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Hagstrom Y, Carlsson J: Prolonged functional impairment after whiplash injury. Scand J Rehabil Med 1996, 28:139–146.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Ettlin TM, Kischka U, Reichmann S, Radii EW, Heim S, Wengen D, Benson DF: Cerebral symptoms after whiplash injury of the neck: a prospective clinical and neuropsychological study of whiplash injury. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1992, 55:943–948.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Schlesinger I, Hering-Hanit R, Dagan Y: Sleep disturbances after whiplash injury: objective and subjective findings. Headache 2001, 41:586–589.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Fischer AJ, Huygen PL, Folgering HT, Verhagen WI, Theunissen EJ: Vestibular hyperreactivity and hyperventilation after whiplash injury. J Neurol Sci 1995, 132:35–43.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Heikkila HV, Wenngren BI: Cervicocephalic kinesthetic sensibility, active range of cervical motion, and oculomotor function in patients with whiplash injury. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 1998, 79:1089–1094.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Hildingsson C, Wenngren BI, Bring G, Toolanen G: Oculomotor problems after cervical spine injury. Acta Orthop Scand 1989, 60:513–516.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Kwan O, Friel J: A review and methodologic critique of the literature supporting 'chronic whiplash injury': Part I - research articles. Med Sci Monit 2003, 9:203–215.Google Scholar
- Aker PD, Gross AR, Goldsmith CH, Pelloso P: Conservative management of mechanical neck pain, systematic overview and meta-analysis. BMJ 1996, 113:1291–1296.Google Scholar
- Rauschning W, Jónsson H: Injuries of the cervical spine in automobile accidents: Pathoanatomic and clinical aspects. In Whiplash injuries. Current concepts in prevention, diagnosis, and treatment of the cervical whiplash syndrome. Edited by: Gunzburg R, Szpalski M. New York: Lippincott-Raven; 1998:33–52.
- Lord SM, Barnsley L, Wallis BJ, Bogduk N: Chronic cervical zygapophysial joint pain after whiplash. A placebo-controlled prevalence study. Spine 1996, 21:1737–1744.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Krakenes J, Kaale BR: Magnetic resonance imaging assessment of craniovertebral ligaments and membranes after whiplash trauma. Spine 2006, 31:2820–2826.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Schofferman J, Bogduk N, Slosar P: Chronic whiplash and whiplash-associated disorders: an evidence-based approach. J Am Acad Orthop Surg 2007, 15:596–606.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Panjabi MM, Ito S, Pearson AM, Ivancic PC: Injury mechanisms of the cervical intervertebral disc during simulated whiplash. Spine 2004, 29:1217–1225.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Freeman MD, Nystrom A, Centeno C: Chronic whiplash and central sensitization, an evaluation of the role of a myofascial trigger points in pain modulation. J Brachial Plex Peripher Nerve Inj 2009, 4:2.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Herren-Gerber R, Weiss S, Arendt-Nielsen L, Petersen-Felix S, Di Stefano G, Radanov BP, Curatolo M: Modulation of central hypersensitivity by nociceptive input in chronic pain after whiplash injury. Pain Med 2004, 5:366–376.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Duffy MF, Stuberg W, DeJong S, Gold KV, Nystrom NA: Case report: whiplash-associated disorder from a low-velocity bumper car collision: history, evaluation, and surgery. Spine 2004, 29:1881–1884.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Hagert CG, Christenson JT: Hyperpressure in the trapezius muscle associated with fibrosis. Acta Orthop Scand 1990, 61:263–265.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Williams WW, Donell ST, Twyman RS, Birch R: The posterior triangle and the painful shoulder: Spinal accessory nerve injury. Ann R Coll Surg Engl 1996, 78:521–525.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Wetmore C, Elde R: Detection and characterization of a sensory microganglion associated with the spinal accessory nerve: a scanning laser confocal microscopic study of the neurons and their processes. J Comp Neurol 1991, 305:148–163.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Bremmer-Smith AT, Unwin AJ, Williams WW: Sensory pathways in the spinal accessory nerve. J Bone Joint Surg Br 1999, 81:226–228.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Battista AF: Complications of biopsy of the cervical lymph node. Surg Gynecol Obstet 1991, 173:142–146.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Gordon SL, Graham WP, Black JT, Miller SH: Accessory nerve function after surgical procedures in the posterior triangle. Arch Surg 1977, 112:264–268.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Woodward G: Spinal accessory neuropathy and internal jugular thrombosis after carotid endarterectomy. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2000, 68:111–112.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Bodack MP, Tunkel RS, Marini SG, Nagler W: Spinal accessory nerve palsy as a cause of pain after whiplash injury: case report. J Pain Symptom Manage 1998, 15:3213–3228.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Nederhand MJ, Ijzerman MJ, Hermens HJ, Baten CT, Zilvold G: Cervical dysfunction in the Chronic Whiplash Associated Disorder Grade II (WAD-II). Spine 2000, 25:1938–1943.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Larsson SE, Bodegard L, Henriksson KG, Oberg PA: Chronic trapezius myalgia. Morphology and blood flow studied in 17 patients. Acta Orthop Scand 1990, 61:394–398.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.